By ConstitutionOwl • Tuesday, November 10, 2026
The Supreme Court on November 9 paused a federal district court injunction that had blocked Homeland Security waivers and associated border construction in the Big Bend Sector of Texas. In an unsigned opinion in Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church, the Court concluded that the government was strongly likely to show the lower court lacked jurisdiction over the challengers’ major-questions claim. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson would have denied the stay.
The distinction at the center of the order is narrow but consequential. The Court treated the challengers’ argument as a claim that the secretary exceeded authority granted by Congress. Invoking the major-questions doctrine, it explained, does not convert a statutory claim into a constitutional one. The stay suspends the preliminary injunction while the government pursues Supreme Court review under the conditions stated in the order; it is not a final decision resolving every claim in the litigation.
The underlying statute helps explain the procedural route. Section 102(c), as amended in 2005, gives the Homeland Security secretary authority to waive legal requirements the secretary determines necessary to expedite specified border barriers and roads. It makes waiver decisions effective on Federal Register publication. It also restricts district-court review to claims alleging a constitutional violation, with a 60-day filing deadline, and provides for Supreme Court review by certiorari rather than an ordinary appeal through a circuit court.
That framework places two questions in sequence: what power Congress gave the executive and what claims Congress allowed courts to hear. A plaintiff’s disagreement with an agency’s reading of a statute does not automatically answer the separate jurisdiction question. The Supreme Court’s order addresses that threshold in the particular litigation before it, even though the dispute concerns construction with visible consequences on the ground.
The district court’s October 14 memorandum supplies the background to its October 2 injunction. The plaintiffs include Friends of the Ruidosa Church, the Center for Biological Diversity and a river guide. They challenged a series of waivers issued between February and July 2026 affecting a long stretch of West Texas borderland. The lower court described the affected area as including national-park, state-park and other public and private land, and recounted the plaintiffs’ arguments about irreparable harm from construction. The plaintiffs brought their lawsuit in April and later sought preliminary relief in August. The lower court’s opinion recounts briefing, a hearing and competing arguments before explaining its decision to intervene.
The next records will be the government’s petition and the Court’s response. If review is denied, the stay ends automatically; if granted, it continues until judgment is sent down. The conditional order changes the immediate construction restraints while leaving the wider litigation unresolved. Readers should distinguish interim relief from final adjudication.
Sources
FOLLOW THE ENTIRE CREW
Daily reporting and newsroom updates from FrontPage Crew.
