By ConstitutionOwl • Thursday, November 12, 2026
The Supreme Court heard arguments November 9 in a dispute over how private pipeline companies must compensate landowners when using condemnation authority under the Natural Gas Act. Hoffmann v. WBI Energy Transmission asks whether state law supplies the measure of compensation. The official docket records the argument, rather than a decision answering that question.
The disagreement arose from easements across North Dakota ranchland. The landowners' brief describes a settlement over the property interests that left open responsibility for litigation expenses. They argue that state compensation rules protect owners from bearing costs associated with losing property through condemnation. Their position distinguishes a private company exercising delegated authority from the federal government taking land in its own name.
The landowners contend that Congress did not specify a compensation standard when it authorized certain pipeline companies to bring eminent-domain actions. In their reading, that silence leaves room for state property rules. They also invoke decisions from other federal appellate courts as support for looking to state law. Those are legal arguments offered by the petitioners; the Court's agreement to hear the case does not mean it has accepted them.
WBI's brief argues that the federal standard governs. It says Congress created the condemnation power to remove state-law obstacles to federally approved interstate pipeline projects. Requiring a company exercising that power to follow varying state compensation standards, the company argues, would restore the patchwork Congress sought to overcome. Its filing also disputes the basis for shifting attorney fees to the condemning company.
The question has consequences beyond the price assigned to a strip of land. A compensation rule can determine whether an owner bears legal and expert expenses in contesting a taking. For project developers, the source of law affects the consistency of obligations across state lines. These competing concerns explain why a technical choice of law can materially change the economics of a condemnation dispute.
The official question presented is narrower than a general referendum on whether pipelines may ever use eminent domain. It concerns compensation in private condemnations under this particular federal statute. A future opinion will need to be read for the rule it adopts and the reasons supporting it; an answer about the governing standard would not automatically settle every valuation disagreement in every project.
For now, the reliable checkpoint is procedural: the case was argued and remains awaiting an announced resolution in the reviewed docket. Landowners and developers can examine both briefs to understand the competing readings, while avoiding predictions based solely on which side a question from the bench appears to favor. The eventual judgment will supply the operative answer that Monday's hearing itself did not.
Sources
FOLLOW THE ENTIRE CREW
Daily reporting and newsroom updates from FrontPage Crew.
