Public Accountability • Friday, November 13, 2026

GAO Renews Call for Clearer FEMA Preparedness-Grant Decisions

A new November 12 review draws together transparency concerns across a $2.9 billion preparedness portfolio and tracks earlier corrective work.

Gideon Marsh — approved human correspondent in a representative reporting setting

Illustrative correspondent image; not a photograph of the reported event.

By Gideon Marsh • Friday, November 13, 2026

The Government Accountability Office renewed its warning Thursday that communities applying for federal preparedness money need clearer explanations of how their projects will be judged. Its November 12 review describes 13 FEMA preparedness grant programs totaling $2.9 billion for fiscal 2026. The new publication draws together recurring findings about application scoring, changing national priorities and risk models rather than announcing that every program has suffered the same failure.

The grants support preparation for terrorism and disasters, including training, equipment, planning and communications. GAO also identifies major-event preparedness, including the 2028 Summer Olympic Games. Its central accountability concern is practical: applicants cannot confidently design proposals around standards they cannot see. The review says FEMA has not consistently explained evaluation criteria, communicated changes to priority areas or supplied enough information about assumptions used in some risk models. These are findings about grant administration, not a declaration that funded equipment provides no security value.

A September 2025 port-security audit illustrates the scoring problem. FEMA, working with the Coast Guard, awarded $690 million across 82 port areas during fiscal 2018 through 2024, with more than half going to eight areas. GAO found the funding announcement did not fully describe all evaluation criteria or other selection factors. It recommended disclosure of the criteria and their relative weights, other factors used in award decisions and an assessment of whether evaluation results matched the program’s distribution goals.

The public recommendation tracker records FEMA’s March 2026 statement that it would put fuller evaluation descriptions into a subsequent port-security funding notice. GAO still lists that recommendation as open. That is a narrower finding than saying FEMA has done nothing: the agency described intended corrective work, while the watchdog had not closed the recommendation. For applicants, publication of understandable criteria and confirmation that the award process follows them are separate tests.

The transit-security record shows why current status matters. GAO’s July 2023 audit found FEMA sometimes selected lower-scoring applications despite its disclosed competitive process. The recommendation page now reports additional evaluation and selection explanations in the funding notice as of February 2026, with those recommendations partly addressed. It also records one completed change: GAO closed the recommendation on documenting risk-model assumptions after FEMA supplied its fiscal 2024 methodology review in January 2025.

Other work remains. The transit tracker says FEMA and partner agencies examined cybersecurity data but did not find a suitable source covering every eligible applicant; GAO continues to seek appropriate cyber-risk information when available. Read alongside Thursday’s synthesis, those records show a mixed implementation picture, with one documented repair and continuing disclosure questions. The useful next measure is whether applicants receive complete rules before competing and whether award data demonstrate that FEMA follows those rules. The new report supplies an oversight agenda, not evidence that every historical recommendation is still untouched.

Sources

Follow the Entire Crew

Follow @FrontPageCrew for daily reporting and newsroom updates.