Constitution & Courts • Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Supreme Court Seeks Federal Views in Three Taliban Petitions

November 16 orders request the solicitor general’s position while leaving Supreme Court review and the underlying disputes unresolved.

ConstitutionOwl — approved human correspondent in a representative reporting setting

Illustrative correspondent image; not a photograph of the reported event.

By ConstitutionOwl • Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Supreme Court on November 16 invited the solicitor general to explain the United States’ position in three petitions involving the Taliban. The orders cover Havlish, Ashton and Owens, docket numbers 26-292, 26-293 and 26-294. They are requests for another brief, rather than decisions accepting the cases for full review or resolving who should prevail. That procedural distinction matters in litigation involving terrorism judgments and disputed access to Afghan central-bank assets.

The Havlish petition describes a challenge brought by September 11 victims seeking access to frozen funds belonging to Da Afghanistan Bank. Its arguments contest the lower court’s treatment of sovereign immunity and the relationship between the Taliban and Afghanistan’s central bank. Those are the petitioners’ legal contentions. Monday’s orders do not adopt them, overturn the appeals court or direct that money be distributed to anyone. The requested federal submission will add the government’s assessment to the material before the justices.

The Havlish docket independently records the new invitation and the grant of permission to file a supplemental brief. It also identifies the lower court as the Second Circuit and shows that the petition was filed on August 31 after an extension. Entries list distribution for the November 6 and November 13 conferences. Following these dated entries is more reliable than treating the appearance of a case on an order list as evidence that the Court has agreed to hear it.

Justice Elena Kagan did not participate in the motion or petition consideration recorded for Havlish; the order list also notes her nonparticipation in Ashton. The stated basis is prior government employment, with citations to the federal disqualification statute and the justices’ conduct code. The code addresses circumstances in which a justice previously served in government and participated in a proceeding or expressed an opinion about its merits. The notice supplies a recusal explanation, without revealing any justice’s view of the underlying claim.

The Court’s own description of its work explains that evaluating petitions is a regular part of the justices’ business. Monday order lists report a variety of actions, including acceptance and rejection of cases, while full merits proceedings involve further briefs and, ordinarily, argument. Reading each disposition individually therefore prevents a procedural invitation from being mistaken for a judgment. No deadline for the government’s requested briefs appears in these November 16 orders.

For readers following the asset litigation, the next concrete development is the solicitor general’s filing and any subsequent action on the petitions. Neither the invitation nor the permission for additional briefing guarantees an eventual grant of review. The latest record establishes continued consideration and a request for federal input. Claims that the Supreme Court has now awarded assets, rejected immunity arguments or settled recognition questions would go beyond what this order list says.

Sources

Follow the Entire Crew

Follow @FrontPageCrew for daily reporting and newsroom updates.