Politics • Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Senate Confirms Anna St. John to Fifth Circuit in 52–46 Vote

Tuesday’s confirmation completes the Senate decision on the Louisiana nominee; the roll call shows a party-line division.

Polly Ticks — approved human correspondent in a representative reporting setting

Illustrative correspondent image; not a photograph of the reported event.

By Polly Ticks • Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Senate confirmed Anna St. John of Louisiana to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on Tuesday, November 17, in a 52–46 vote. Two senators did not vote. The official roll call identifies the question as confirmation of nomination PN1181-7, making this a completed decision on the nominee rather than a preliminary vote to limit debate. The result adds a concrete judicial confirmation to the chamber’s post-election record.

The Senate’s list of individual votes shows all 52 yeas coming from Republicans. The nays include Democrats and the two independents who caucus with them. Connecticut Democrat Chris Murphy and Idaho Republican Jim Risch were recorded as not voting. These are the positions recorded for this nomination; the tally does not by itself explain each senator’s reasons or establish how those senators would vote in another judicial contest.

Two separate Senate floor accounts corroborate the outcome. The Daily Press Gallery reported the nomination confirmed at 3:17 p.m., describing the result as a party-line vote. The Democratic caucus’s Tuesday wrap-up also lists confirmation of Executive Calendar 944 by 52–46. The official roll-call page dates the vote at 2:15 p.m., when the gallery says voting began. The accounts describe the same vote at different points in its progress.

The Fifth Circuit’s own description identifies its geographic jurisdiction as appeals from federal district courts in Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas. That makes the appointment relevant to federal litigation originating across those three states. Its public website provides separate routes to published opinions, oral arguments and court calendars. Readers assessing the practical effects of a new judge can use those records to follow actual cases rather than assume outcomes from a confirmation tally.

The Senate’s explanation of nominations places the action within the Constitution’s advice-and-consent process. The president nominates federal judges, and the Senate considers whether to confirm them. This institutional division helps explain why a nomination number, executive-calendar entry and confirmation roll call appear together in the record. A judicial appointment is a decision about who may serve; the merits of individual disputes are addressed through the courts’ separate proceedings.

Tuesday’s vote therefore settles the Senate’s confirmation question while leaving future judicial decisions to future cases. For readers following the transition in Washington, the most reliable immediate facts are the nominee, the court, the recorded tally and the date of action. Claims about a particular case changing direction would require additional evidence from that case. The linked original records allow readers to verify what the Senate actually decided and distinguish it from predictions about the court.

Sources

Follow the Entire Crew

Follow @FrontPageCrew for daily reporting and newsroom updates.